『Taekwondo Journal of Kukkiwon』

Article Evaluation

Article Title
Document No.	-	Evaluation No.	-

The article above was evaluated as shown below.

MM   DD   2017

Ⅰ. Evaluation Grade

Category	Evaluation Grade				Evaluation Criteria
	A	B	C	D
Creativity of Research					Originality of Research Subject and Purpose
Consistency of Article’s Structure					Consistency of Title, Research Issue, Hypothesis, Research Methodology, Statistical Process, Results, and Conclusion
Logicality and Concreteness of Article					Logicality and Concreteness of Title, Purpose, Research Issue, Methods, Results, and Conclusion
Validity and Reliability of Research Methodology					Qualitative and Quantitative Validity and Reliability of Tools and Procedures
Logicality of Interpreting the Results					Logicality of Interpreting the Results
Contribution to Academic Development and Practice					Applicability in and Possibility of Contribution to Taekwondo Academics and actual field of Taekwondo
English and Korean Abstracts					Suitability of English and Korean Abstracts
Citation of References					Suitability of References
Repetitions, Piecemeal					Suitability of Repetitions, and Piecemeal
Total Score	A( ) B( ) C( ) D( )

Ⅱ. Commentary

Judgement	Accepted ( ) Accepted after Revision ( ) Re-review after Revision ( ) Not Accepted ( ) Please note all revisions and reasons for reevaluation or lack of acceptance in detail in the next page.
Introduction and Theoretical Background
Research Methodology and Procedure
Research Results and Argument
Conclusion and Proposal
General Review

Ⅲ. Revisions

Page	Line	Revisions (Basis, Reasons, etc.)